Reviewing the Best Shaving Creams

Not all shaving creams are created equal—check out our picks for the smoothest shave!

  (photo credit: PR)
(photo credit: PR)

Our Top Picks

Jump to Review
Anthony Shaving Cream
Jump to Review
Harry's Shaving Cream
Jump to Review
Loved01 Shaving Cream
Jump to Review
The Art of Shaving Shaving Cream
Jump to Review
Gillette Shaving Cream

Man or woman, once puberty hits, we all pick up the razor and start nicking ourselves weekly to get rid of unwanted hair. But as we get older, we realize that shaving can take a toll on our skin, leading to cuts, razor bumps, ingrown hairs, and worse. That's when we start seeking products to minimize these issues—like shaving creams. And that’s probably why you’re here! Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. We’ve gathered a selection of shaving creams that tackle specific shaving-related problems, each with its own unique benefits. Just scroll down to explore our top picks and find the one that best meets your needs.

1

Anthony Shaving Cream

Anthony Shaving Cream
Anthony Shaving Cream

Nobody wants to start their day dealing with redness or irritation after a shave. That's exactly why this shaving cream is made with special ingredients added specifically for those with sensitive skin. It features squalene, an organic oil, to help reduce friction, so you get a close shave without those annoying nicks and cuts. For those prone to breakouts, it includes eucalyptus and rosemary that work to keep those pores clean without harsh chemicals. What’s really cool (literally) is how it uses hops to create a cooling sensation without numbing your skin. This means you can avoid over-shaving, which is something that often happens with other shaving creams. All these ingredients give it a light herbal scent that’s fresh but not overpowering. And to top it off, it has a foamy lotion texture that softens your beard hairs and it’s free of all the bad stuff like parabens and phthalates.

Rated 9.9 based on 10
JPOST
Pros & Cons
Soothes sensitive skin
Refreshing eucalyptus scent
Prevents acne
Some find it hard to lather

2

Harry's Shaving Cream

Harry
Harry

Dry and tight skin after shaving can be a real mood killer first thing in the morning. That's why this shaving cream is all about getting you off to a smooth and fresh start. The key here is in the formula, which is infused with hydrating ingredients like aloe and cucumber that leave your face feeling moisturized and cool, instead of parched and tight. The cream's rich consistency creates a cushion between your razor and your skin, so you can glide your razor over it without irritating or pulling your skin. Plus, using it is super simple. Just warm up the water, wet your face, massage it into your skin, and get a shave that’s closer, more comfortable, and leaves you refreshed enough to take on the day!

Rated 9.6 based on 10
JPOST
Pros & Cons
Aloe enriched formula
Smooth lather
Moisturizing
The scent may be a bit strong for some

3

Loved01 Shaving Cream

Loved01 Shaving Cream
Loved01 Shaving Cream

Shaving can come with unique challenges for people of color, like razor bumps, ingrown hairs, and hyperpigmentation. But don't worry, this shaving cream is formulated specifically for melanin-rich skin and includes ingredients that combat these exact problems. It features ingredients like rosehip, sea buckthorn, and jojoba oils that balance your skin’s moisture and lock in the hydration to leave your skin feeling soft all day. This, combined with the lightweight formula rich in fatty acids and ceramides, softens your hair to make shaving easier and less irritating for your skin. And for those mindful of ethical consumption, you’ll be happy to know it’s vegan, cruelty-free, and completely free of harsh chemicals!

Rated 9.5 based on 10
JPOST
Pros & Cons
Made for melanin-rich skin
Includes jojoba oil for hydration
Fragrance-free formula
Contains a mild natural scent from the included oils

4

The Art of Shaving Shaving Cream

The Art of Shaving Shaving Cream
The Art of Shaving Shaving Cream

When a shaving cream lathers up thick and rich, it doesn't just feel nice and fancy, but actually lifts and softens your hairs. This makes it easier for your razor to really get in there and do its job with fewer swipes, less tugging, and way less irritation. The fourth shaving cream on our list nails this by creating a creamy lather that acts like a cushion between your skin and the blade, which improves your razor's glide and reduces friction. This means you’re less likely to deal with redness or razor burn after you’re done. But the best part is that a good lather helps your razor blades last longer and saves you from constantly buying replacements!

Rated 9.2 based on 10
JPOST
Pros & Cons
Clinically tested for sensitivity
Protects against razor burn
Unscented
Costs a bit more than other options

5

Gillette Shaving Cream

Gillette Shaving Cream
Gillette Shaving Cream

If you’re someone who shaves regularly, finding a shaving cream that’s cost-effective and lasts a while is a real win. This set, for example, has twelve bottles filled with eleven ounces of shaving cream that will last you months before you have to buy another one. It’s not just about quantity, though. The real magic is in the formula, which is loaded with aloe to keep your skin hydrated and soothed, especially if your skin is sensitive and prone to razor burns. The thick lather feels like foam and spreads easily to create an even base. This reduces friction and protects your skin from getting irritated. And the best part is that when you rinse it off, your skin feels soft and hydrated, not dry or rough.

Rated 9 based on 10
JPOST
Pros & Cons
Affordable
Convenient bulk packaging
Reduces cuts and burns
Not unscented

6

eos Shaving Cream

eos Shaving Cream
eos Shaving Cream

Shaving isn't just about getting the job done, but also about starting your morning on the right note or making yourself feel a little pampered before you head to bed. This shaving cream is precisely formulated to make a simple shower feel like a mini-spa moment. It makes each shave smell like a blend of vanilla bean, sweet cream, and brown sugar, which lingers long after you're out of the shower. But it’s not just about smelling great. This cream is filled with 100% natural shea butter and aloe to keep your skin feeling soft and deeply hydrated for up to 24 hours after shaving. The formula is also dermatologist-approved and gynecologist-approved, so it's gentle enough to use on your legs, underarms, and even your bikini line without worrying about razor bumps.

Rated 8.9 based on 10
JPOST
Pros & Cons
Rich vanilla scent
Includes shea butter for moisturization
Cost-effective
Leaves a slightly slippery residue in the shower that needs to be cleaned

7

Dollar Shave Club Shaving Cream

Dollar Shave Club Shaving Cream
Dollar Shave Club Shaving Cream

Nobody likes dealing with those irritating razor bumps or ingrown hairs that pop up after shaving. So let us introduce you to the shaving cream that was made to solve this exact problem. Unlike traditional creams, this formula uses a special blend of shave butter, which not only softens your hair within seconds but also provides a more precise shave. This means fewer cuts and less irritation, which is a major win for anyone prone to razor bumps. And because it’s made with sensitive skin in mind, it’s super gentle while still reducing the chances of ingrown hairs to keep your skin smooth and flawless. The best part, though, is that it's translucent, so you can clearly see each and every hair you need to shave off and spend way less time with one leg up on the side of the tub!

Rated 8.6 based on 10
JPOST
Pros & Cons
Prevents ingrown hairs
Translucent formula for visibility
Softens hair to avoid bumps
Thicker consistency requires some extra rinsing

FAQ

Q: How does the type of lather in a shaving cream affect the quality of the shave?

A: A rich, creamy lather helps lift and soften the hair, making it easier for the razor to glide smoothly without tugging or pulling. This reduces the risk of cuts, irritation, and razor burn. Creams that create a thick lather also act as a cushion between the blade and the skin, which helps protect against nicks and cuts. On the other hand, thin or watery lathers might not provide enough lubrication or protection and make the shave less comfortable.

Q: What is the difference between traditional shaving creams and gel-based formulas?

A: Traditional creams often produce a rich, foamy lather that lifts hair and provides a thicker protective layer on the skin. This helps achieve a close, comfortable shave with minimal irritation. Gel-based formulas, on the other hand, typically create a clear or semi-transparent layer. This transparency allows for better visibility, which is ideal for detailed or precision shaving. Gel-based products also focus more on hydration, and are often preferred by those with sensitive skin.

Q: How should I store shaving cream to maintain its effectiveness?

A: To keep your shaving cream in the best condition, store it in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight or heat. High temperatures or humidity can change the consistency of the cream, making it runny or too thick. If your shaving cream comes in a pressurized can, it’s crucial to keep it away from extreme temperatures to avoid any risk of leaking or bursting.

Q: How do shaving creams with natural ingredients compare to those with synthetic components?

A: Shaving creams with natural ingredients often use plant-based oils and extracts, like shea butter, coconut oil, or aloe vera, which can help hydrate and soothe the skin. These natural ingredients are gentler and less likely to irritate, making them a great option for those with sensitive skin. In contrast, creams with synthetic components might offer a longer shelf life or create a stronger lather, but they can sometimes include harsher chemicals or artificial fragrances.

Q: What are the benefits of using a shaving brush with traditional shaving creams?

A: Using a shaving brush has several benefits that elevate your shaving experience. A brush helps create a thicker and more luxurious lather by whipping air into the shaving cream. It also distributes the cream evenly over your skin and lifts the hairs, allowing the razor to cut more effectively and closely. Additionally, the bristles of the brush gently exfoliate the skin, removing dead skin cells and reducing the risk of ingrown hairs.This results in a smoother, irritation-free shave and extends the life of your razor blades by creating a more protective layer.

Article Contributors

JPost Advisor Team

The Jpost Shopping team offers expert picks and insights, helping you find lifestyle-enhancing products. Independent of the newsroom and reader-supported, our team of writers and product enthusiasts also use AI to ensure product dimensions, availability, and pricing are accurate.