Prosecutors are pursuing the death penalty against Robert Bowers, who is accused of killing 11 worshippers at the Tree of Life synagogue in October 2018.
Court filings showing the offer’s rejection were released Tuesday.
Lawyers for Bowers told the court that the case would already be over if the government had accepted the plea. A proposed schedule for trial would have jury selection begin in September.
Some members of the congregations that met at Tree of Life urged the government to avoid the pain of a protracted trial, Pittsburgh CBS affiliate KDKA reported.
“That is way too long a time for closure, which I think is what is important for a congregation and for the families,” said New Light Congregation co-president Stephen Cohen, who wrote a letter in August urging the U.S. attorney general to accept the plea deal.
Judah Samet, who survived the shooting, told KDKA that putting Bowers to death would let him off the hook.
“I don’t want to kill because, to me, it would be a gift to him,” Samet said. “He won’t suffer.”