The hearing in Congress on Dec. 5 could hardly have been more consequential: Two of the three Ivy League university presidents who testified about antisemitism on their campuses soon resigned, while their leading interrogator, Republican Rep. Elise Stefanik, morphed into an unlikely hero for American Jews, including many who tend to lean liberal.
Now, the congressional panel investigating antisemitism on college campuses is, for the first time, reconvening to grill another college president about what’s been happening at her school amid protests over the Israel-Hamas war. They have subpoenaed Nemat Shafik, president of Columbia University, which has been a hotbed of tensions since the war’s start with Hamas’ attack on Israel on Oct. 7.
Shafik, an Egyptian-born economist who goes by the first name Minouche, had only been in charge of the Ivy League university in New York City for three days at the time. Since, she has navigated thorny questions about who can protest, and how, in a setting that is devoted to the contesting of ideas while also seeking to assure Jewish students that the campus is safe for them.
Here’s what to know about Shafik, what has happened at Columbia and what to look for during Wednesday’s hearing:
Shafik has previously worked at the International Monetary Fund and World Bank. Her track record means she has more, and recent, experience in public diplomacy than the presidents of Harvard University and the University of Pennsylvania, both career higher education administrators, when they stumbled before the panel in December. At the same time, Shafik cautioned in an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal on Tuesday, “It is essential to remember that universities and their presidents aren’t politicians.”
Shafik also has the advantage of going second and has already gotten ahead of the question that tripped up the other university presidents: whether calls for the genocide of Jews violate their schools’ codes of conduct. In the Wall Street Journal op-ed, titled “What I Plan to Tell Congress Tomorrow,” Shafik wrote that calling for genocide “has no place in a university community. Such words are outside the bounds of legitimate debate and unimaginably harmful.” The other presidents declined to offer a clear answer to the question, saying that their responses would depend on “context.”
But Shafik did not spell out a position on one of the most divisive phrases associated with pro-Palestinian protests, “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.” Many critics of the phrase argue that it is antisemitic because it amounts to a call for the destruction of Israel; 70 Democratic lawmakers explicitly called it “a rallying cry … for the genocide of the Jewish people” in advance of a Republican-led congressional vote to censure Rep. Ilhan Omar for using the first half of the phrase. We can expect to see Shafik asked for details here.
Under Shafik’s leadership, Columbia has taken steps to blunt the most disruptive protests. It has defined a limited space for protest and penalized students who rally outside it. Two student groups that have led pro-Palestinian protests, Students for Justice in Palestine and Jewish Voice for Peace, were suspended in November for what the school said were violations of protest rules; they remain suspended at present. The university also frequently closes its urban campus to outsiders when disruptive protests are anticipated, including when thousands of activists descended on the campus to protest the treatment of the pro-Palestinian groups. And this month, it suspended four students who participated in a “Resistance 101” event that praised Hamas.
After early incidents in which a swastika was found on campus and a Jewish pro-Israel student was allegedly assaulted, Columbia has also taken active steps to address antisemitism on campus. Shafik convened an antisemitism task force after the war began, and last month, the task force released its first report, concluding that Jewish students on campus feel “isolation and pain” and that the university was not consistently enforcing rules barring unauthorized protests. The task force’s chair, David Schizer, is a law professor and former CEO of the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee who will also be testifying; expect to hear him asked about the committee’s work and conclusions.
Not everyone on campus is satisfied with the university’s efforts to constrain protests and make Jewish students feel safe. In addition to those who argue that the limits on protest inappropriately curtail free speech, one Jewish professor in particular has emerged as a leading figure criticizing universities for permitting anti-Israel sentiment to flourish and bleed into antisemitism. Shai Davidai, an Israeli who teaches in Columbia’s business school, broke into public view just weeks after Oct. 7, when a video of an impassioned speech he gave denouncing Columbia and saying that its Jewish students are not safe went viral. He maintains a national audience and continues to sound the alarm about what is happening on campus, giving potential fodder to those at the hearing who may want to embarrass the school.
Shafik appears prepared not just to defend herself against aggressive questioning but to present her own views about how to balance free speech and student safety on college campuses, a tradeoff at the heart of contemporary culture wars surrounding higher education. In her Wall Street Journal op-ed, she outlines four lessons she has learned since Oct. 7, writing, “My own view is that official university statements should be limited to issues that speak directly to life on campus. The university should return to its core mission of fostering a range of perspectives and the scholarship, discoveries and good citizenship that flow from it. At the same time, students and faculty should feel unconstrained in developing their own opinions. … we should become models for how people grow and thrive when they live side by side with others who are different.”
Columbia's controversial history with antisemitism on campus
This is not the first time Columbia has been in the spotlight for allegations of campus antisemitism. A controversy over the treatment of pro-Israel students on the campus two decades ago made national headlines and brought Bari Weiss, then a student activist, to prominence; Weiss’ Free Press publication has advanced the antisemitism case against higher education since Oct. 7 Years later, Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmedinejad, a Holocaust denier, spoke on campus. In the years since the school, which has a large Jewish population including students from Israel, has been the site of ongoing protest surrounding Israel.
Jewish Columbia students share experiences of antisemitism, discrimination on campus ahead of Congressional hearing
Jewish students, faculty and staff live and work in fear on Columbia University's campus, House Committee on Education and the Workforce Chairwoman Rep. Virginia Foxx (R-NC) said Wednesday morning during a news conference ahead of university president Minouche Shafik's testimony before the Committee on Capitol Hill.
"Today's hearing will expose the pervasive and extreme antisemitism present at Columbia and allow Congress to hold the university leaders accountable for their unacceptable dereliction of their duty to protect students, Jewish students and staff," Foxx said. "Columbia University must confront anti semitism aggressively and unequivocally."
Students aren't going to be able to get a good education if they are distracted for fear of their lives or for fear of being accosted on their campuses, Foxx said, and the healing is about the role of the university in terms of focusing on allowing students to get a good education.
Two Jewish students spoke about their experiences on campuses in the wake of October 7.
Yola Ashkenazie, a junior, said Jewish students have been subjected to an endless barrage of rhetoric and divisive actions that have left them marginalized and unsafe.
"We have been harassed with hateful slogans in the dorms, dining halls and classrooms. All we've asked for is to be left alone, protected on campus and able to study in peace," Ashkenazie said.
Eden Yadegar, a senior and president of Columbia's chapter of Students Supporting Israel, is a first-generation American of Iranian immigrants who fled Iran in the face of religious persecution.
Yadegar participated in the Committee's roundtable on antisemitism on college campuses on February 29.
"Six weeks later, I am disheartened to say that this fact remains: the Jewish community at Columbia is alone," Yadegar said.
Yadegar accused Columbia's administration for idly sitting by as a tsunami of antisemitism in the forms of harassment, bullying, exclusion, intimidation and physical violence "flooded every aspect of campus life."
In February, Foxx announced the Committee expanded its list of Ivy League schools under investigation for antisemitism to include Columbia and requested troves of documents from the University on its handling of antisemitism and discrimination on campus.