Holocaust Remembrance Day: Jews need to hear hard truths about Oct. 7 - opinion
The major fault of Oct. 7 lies with Jewish leaders who minimized threats from the Iranian ayatollah and his armored pawns, Hamas and Hezbollah.
By ROBERT SCOTT KELLNER
This year’s International Holocaust Remembrance Day on January 27 follows closely upon an almost unimaginable event that exposed the horrific cost of our failure to end antisemitism.Who bears the fault for the terrors of October 7, 2023, when Hamas murderers stormed into Israel from Gaza? The killers, of course, whose genocidal intentions are apparent in their Charter. But the Israel Defense Forces, AWOL from their posts, played a role. As did the Israeli people who wildly assailed each other over internal issues while the bloodthirsty enemy at their border plotted their deaths.However, the major fault did not occur on that day in October. That heavy burden lies with Jewish leaders who minimized threats from the Iranian ayatollah and his armored pawns, Hamas and Hezbollah.
Opting to appease and placate aggressive Islamic nations, Jewish leaders joined Western nations in denouncing as “hate speech” the factually correct description, “Islamic jihadist fanatics.” Moreover, they championed the Palestinians’ demands for territory, convinced that their liberality would irresistibly lead to friendship and peace.Instead of steadfastly confronting those who slandered Jews and threatened to destroy Israel, Jewish leaders fixated on educating the world about the six million Jews killed by Nazis in the Holocaust, fully expecting the individual stories of Jewish victims to arouse sympathy, compassion, and understanding, which would then naturally dispel antisemitism. Their noble efforts proved delusional. Despite a fortune spent on Holocaust museums, the slogan “Never Again” carved on the museum walls did not protect Jews from being beaten while strolling in Brooklyn, or shot while at prayer in their synagogue in Pittsburgh.Even the heartrending story of Anne Frank, the young Jewish girl hiding from the Nazis, whose diary has been vital reading for tens of millions of young girls, could not move Time magazine’s “Person of the Year,” Taylor Swift, to rally her fans (“Swifties”) and speak out for the release of a young Jewish Swiftie, taken hostage by the Hamas invaders. The unlucky girl was murdered.Our world looks away in silence, just as it did when the grandparents of today’s besieged Jews were prey for beasts.
A DIARY from the Nazi era that addresses these matters and assigns accountability for the Jew-hatred that plagued his country was written by Friedrich Kellner, a German justice inspector and Social Democrat who had campaigned during the Weimar Republic against Hitler and his Nazi party. When Hitler came to power, Kellner began his diary (while under Gestapo surveillance) to record Nazi crimes. He considered it a “weapon of truth” for future generations to use against their own Nazis.
As for the world looking away in silence, Kellner criticized his own Evangelical Lutheran Church for not caring about the vast amount of casualties during World War I. He added: “The Church in Germany during this war says nothing about the terrible atrocities committed against the Jews.”About Jews being prey for beasts: “The Nazis’ entire action against the Jews – who are no worse than people in general – is because rulers need a scapegoat to divert attention away from their own crimes. It is the same as throwing down a piece of meat to distract the beasts.”Kellner’s first diary entry about Arabs was to show Hitler’s policy of using radio broadcasts to incite Arab resentment against Jews. “The lack of any goodwill on our side is clear to see in Palestine,” Kellner wrote. “At the same time in the 1930s that we were throwing Jews out of Germany, we roused up the Arabs through radio and press to resist Jewish settlement there.”Hitler paid the grand mufti of Jerusalem, Amin al-Husseini, to broadcast antisemitic propaganda over Radio Berlin. In March 1944, al-Husseini urged Arabs to commit genocide: “Rise as one man and fight for your sacred rights. Kill the Jews wherever you find them. This pleases God, history, and religion. This saves your honor. God is with you.”The grand mufti was especially useful in raising volunteers to form the Arab Legion in Hitler’s army. “Arabs in German uniforms?” wrote Kellner. “Must we now create that? And the hypocritical Nazis are being so solicitous about their Islamic customs and religion! In an emergency, the devil eats flies.”After the war, when the Soviet Union took over the role of supporting Palestinian terrorist groups against the Jews, Friedrich Kellner called the connection between atheist Russia and jihadist Islam “an unholy alliance of totalitarian fanatics” and warned it would seriously challenge democracies in the future.As we commemorate the victims of the Nazis, we must be honest about the role of those in the Islamic world who openly threaten Israel and Jews with a second Holocaust. The frightening difference this time is that concentration camps won’t have to be built, and railroad cars won’t be needed, because today’s enemies of the Jewish people plan to drop a nuclear bomb on Israel, where the next six million Jewish victims are already in place.The writer, a navy veteran, is a retired English professor who taught at the University of Massachusetts and Texas A&M University. The grandson of Friedrich Kellner, he published the diary in Germany in 2011. He is the editor and translator of My Opposition: The Diary of Friedrich Kellner – A German Against the Third Reich, Cambridge University Press, United Kingdom.