No holds barred: Is Putin a friend to the Jews who deserves support?
There are many in the global Jewish community who support Putin because he is good to the Jews of Russia.
By SHMULEY BOTEACHNetanyahu and Putin meet in Mascow 370(photo credit: Koby Gideon/GPO)
Wow. This one’s a real cliffhanger.I’m writing this column on Purim, as the people of Crimea are at the polling stations deciding if they’re going to annex themselves to Putin’s Russia or remain part of Ukraine. By the time this is published you’ll already know the outcome. But for me it’s still in the future.Putin’s got 18,000 heavily armed troops in the province.He called the election and gave the pro-Ukraine guys about 15 minutes to campaign. He’s kind of indicated that if the vote doesn’t go his way he might get kind of angry.Gosh. I wonder what the people of Crimea will decide? But I’m going to venture a wild guess here. Putin wins? Welcome to a world where a thug’s expansionist dreams are beginning to be reality.Vladimir Putin has established his credentials over the past decade as an international bully, a KGB apparatchik who suppresses political dissent with oppression and murder, a gangster who subjected Pussy Riot’s members, in prison, to “endless humiliations,” including forced gynecological examinations almost every day for three weeks. A man who would treat women this way just because they oppose him politically deserves the condemnation of the world as a violent brute.Still, there are many in the global Jewish community who support Putin because he is good to the Jews of Russia.There can be little doubt that he is. Ending the centuries old anti-Semitism which was endemic to Russia and claimed the lives of endless hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions, in state-sponsored pogroms, Putin is the man principally responsible for the $50 million Jewish museum of Moscow, to which he also donated a month of his official salary. (Don’t worry, a man estimated to have $75 billion isn’t going hungry any time soon.) He has been extremely good to Chabad, giving them official state recognition. He also seems to be good to Israel, establishing strong diplomatic relations with a nation he says has a natural connection to Russia, given Israel’s million- strong Russian-speaking community. Should we Jews love this guy? Does it matter that he’s deeply immoral when we have so few friends as it is? This was the question that confronted Israel in its relationship with apartheid South Africa. Much of the world embraced the hate-filled Arab global boycott of Israel, which forced Israel to look for trading partners where it could find them. The South African government was a willing friend when few others would have anything to do with the Jewish state. Israel was fighting for its very life. So it did business with South Africa.A few decades later I wonder if anyone believes that was a good idea. No people are more deeply opposed to racism than the Jews, and not just because we suffered its effects but because we are the ones who taught through the Torah that every human being is created equally in the image of God. A deeply immoral government like apartheid South Africa was anathema to the central teachings of Judaism. I understand that Israel was caught between a rock and a hard place. Some argued that it was analogous to the allies partnering with Stalin – the second biggest murderer in the history of the world – in order to defeat Hitler. It was a necessary evil.But I have a different take on the matter.
I believe that the Jewish people are hated by the world because of their sacred mission to spread the Ten Commandments and ethical monotheism. That’s why, whenever there is someone truly wicked, like Hitler or Stalin, they always hate the Jews first. We are the canaries in the coal mine when it comes to world evil. They attack us first, Nazism and Islamist fascism did. But the world is not too far behind.Therefore, whenever a man or a country is wicked, however good they may temporarily be to the Jews, the friendship will not last. They will eventually turn on the Jews since our mission is to spread morality. And can we really support dictators who are our friends if they are murderous and immoral? Does that not contravene everything we are about? Can the Jewish community befriend a man who is the shield protecting mass murderer Bashar Assad, who gasses innocent Arab children? Can we have any relationship with a man that facilitates such evil? Take a closer look and you will see that not only is Putin not the friend to Israel we think he is, but that he actually poses a huge danger. Who is the biggest international defender of Iran at the UN? Putin’s Russia.Moreover, in 2012 Putin had Deputy Foreign Minister Gennady Gatilov warn Israel against “any possible military scenario against Iran” which he threatened would be “catastrophic for the region and for the whole system of international relations. Therefore I hope Israel understands all these consequences... and they should also consider the consequences of such action for themselves.”Some friend.Russia has also called the international sanctions against Iran “overt blackmail” and a “crude contradiction of international law.”In September, 2013, The Daily Mail quoted a Kremlin source as saying that Putin was preparing to offer Iran “missile systems and a second nuclear reactor... If it goes ahead Iran will be supplied with five advanced S-300 surface- to-air missiles, capable of taking down aircraft or guided missiles, valued at $800m.”With Iran threatening to wipe Israel off the map one can only wonder why Putin, the great friend of the Jews, is protecting Iran’s nuclear program and arming Iran with advanced weapons systems.The answer, of course, is that Putin has no friends. He is your typical narcissistic, megalomaniacal dictator who will cultivate friendships that burnish his image. And for now it suits his purposes to feign attachment to the Jews.As to Chabad of Russia’s friendship with Putin, the Lubavitcher Rebbe made it clear that Russia had stolen the celebrated “Schneerson Library” accumulated by successive Chabad leaders. He had the movement launch lawsuits and use every diplomatic connection to retrieve the stolen archive from Russia. Putin has categorically refused to return it, offering to exhibit it in the Jewish museum in Moscow instead. How some in Chabad have accepted this “deal,” given the Rebbe’s ferocious opposition to it, continues to mystify.Always beware a dictator. When he falls righteous people will point fingers. And you really don’t want to be around.The author, whom Newsweek and The Washington Post call “the most famous rabbi in America,” is the only rabbi to have won the London Times Preacher of the Year competition and is the international best-selling author of 30 books. In May he will publish Kosher Lust: Love is Not the Answer. His website is www.shmuley.com. Follow him on Twitter @RabbiShmuley.
