The first bemoaned Israel’s poor performance on the latest PISA tests; the second accused the IDF of systematically inflating the number of haredi (ultra-Orthodox) recruits enlisted each year since the law was changed to increase their participation in military service.
At first glance, these stories have little in common. One is about unequal shouldering of Israel’s national security burden and accusations of deliberate misinformation. The other is about declining educational standards and accurate data placing Israel in the company of nations like Jordan and Belarus rather than the advanced Western economies with which it prefers to keep company.
However, a closer look reveals two similarities.
First, neither story is surprising. Although the IDF has not before been caught in quite so explicit a case of misinformation, it has for years presented recruitment statistics in formats that are apt to mislead. For example, when reporting proportions of women, Ethiopians, Muslims and haredim recruited each year, the IDF has employed inconsistent phrasing and forms of graphic representation to underplay discrepancies between populations. Some reports refer to the percentage of deferrals instead of a percentage of recruits. Others report only absolute numbers of recruits instead of percents recruited from those eligible. And relevant base rates, such as population growth in each population, are routinely ignored.
Similarly, declining standards and growing gaps in Israeli education are no secret. After previous PISA results – which were also disappointing, just a little less so – some sought to attribute them to the achievement gap between Arab and Jewish pupils. However, the data show such excuses lack any foundation. Even after controlling for the performance of Israel’s Arab minority (which accounts for around 20% of pupils who participated in PISA), Israel’s scores are well below the OECD average.
Second, in both cases, the public outcry focuses on surface symptoms rather than the underlying problems. As such, it risks leaving the problems intact.
IN THE case of haredi army service, the problem is a law that the IDF has no appetite to implement and the government has no political will to enforce. Yes, it is wrong to “massage” statistics to avoid criticism, and we should expect more of our armed forces. But such manipulations are common whenever and wherever rapid progress is demanded with respect to some public, quantitative objective. It happened in Soviet Union in the 1930s with respect to five-year plans, and in the United States in the 1990s with No Child Left Behind.
In the case of Israel’s PISA performance, the problem is not where we place relative to Finland or to Lebanon. The problem is that our performance continues to decline relative to our own previous performance, and the achievement gap between Jewish and Arab pupils continues to widen, despite the huge sums of taxpayer money invested over the course of a decade to address these issues. Not only is our education system failing but it appears to lack the capacity to improve.
Calls to punish the “culprits” are a diversion. Court-martialing the officers responsible for publishing inaccurate recruitment data or blaming the Education Minister or teachers for disappointing PISA results won’t change anything. It will leave the edifices of national service and public education hanging precariously at the same angle as before, ready to topple over at the next earthquake.
The integration of haredim into the military and the kinds of educational reform required to teach critical thinking effectively cannot be addressed by executive fiat or within the term of office of a single minister. They are deeper and more complex than that. When we demand immediate results, we encourage our public servants to waste precious resources on quick fixes, or even worse, to pretend we’re doing better than we are.
Israel urgently needs an independent, national body to advise the government on long-range social challenges such as these, and provide up-to-date, reliable data on our progress. As the search this week for culprits demonstrated once again, only an independent body can provide the transparency and continuity needed to help our public institutions make real, rather than cosmetic, progress. Instead of spin to make leaning towers look straight, we need honest analysis and determined action to create a less-crooked reality.
The writer is a visiting professor and Israel Institute scholar at the Graduate School of Education and Human Development of The George Washington University. His research examines connections between cognition, culture and identity. He has led programs in leadership development in Israel for more than 20 years.